Caryn Colbert is listed in the credits for the following albums:
| Year | Artist | Album | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1990 | Breakfast With Amy | Everything Was Beautiful and Nothing Hurt | Guitar |
| 1991 | Breakfast With Amy | Dad | Guitar, Vocals |
| 1992 | Plague of Ethyls | Plague of Ethyls | Producer, Bass, Guitars, Vocals |
| 1992 | Breakfast With Amy | Product #BVCD3482 (Love Gift) | Guitar |
| 1992 | L.S.U. | Grape Prophet, The | Background Vocals |
| 1995 | The Choir | Speckled Bird | Backing Vocals |
| 1995 | The Prayer Chain | Mercury | Vocal |
